A Journey from Judicial Restraint to Judicial Adventurism

Indian Judiciary, an integrated and unified organ is the protector and guarantor of fundamental rights of the Indian citizens. Besides that, it also performs the function of interpretation and evaluation of Indian constitution because constitution is the law of the land and constitution is supreme in Indian Parliamentary System.
When all the functions related to the governance of the nation, i.e., Planning, action and evaluation are assigned to three different organs i.e., legislature, executive and judiciary respectively, it is based on the Doctrine of Separation of Power, i.e., Nobody can interfere in the functioning of other organs.
Eminent makers of Indian constitution decided to provide more powers to Indian judiciary, getting influenced with American system of Judicial Review and Powerful Judiciary.
It is very interesting to recapitalize the whole journey of Indian judiciary trying to justify the doctrine of separation of powers and now facing the criticism as judicial activism and judicial adventurism.
First phase of this journey can be labelled as Judicial restraint which was evident in Shankari Prasad and Sajjan Singh cases respectively. During this period of 1950s, judiciary decided not to declare any act and law made by Parliament as null and void. As a result, no parliamentary act was announced unconstitutional. But at the same time, Indian parliament was also playing very safe, by putting all its acts related to land reforms into Ninth Schedule of Constitution which will be beyond the judicial scrutiny. So, Judiciary did not have powers to review any act placed in the ninth schedule.
Judiciary entered in the second phase of its very challenging journey of Judicial Review which was pronounced in judgment of Golaknath case and Keshvananda Bharti case. In former, Supreme Court declared that parliament does not have power to amend the constitution under article 368 of Indian constitution. Rather this article 368, only explains the procedure how to amend the constitution.
This judicial pronouncement at that time definitely strained the relationship between law making and law evaluative organs of the system.
During 1970s, the tool of judicial review was applied in the historic case of Keshvananda Bharti delivering the “Doctrine of Basic Structure”. As a consequence, parliament was provided limited amending powers without disturbing the basic framework and cardinal features of Indian Constitution.
Still Indian parliament continued with the tradition of putting its acts into ninth schedule, so that they are kept beyond the scope of Judicial review.
With Politico-Administrative changes taking place, judiciary happen to declare in 2007 that No Blanket Immunity can be declared for the ninth schedule. Indian judiciary has all its powers of judicial review even for all those items placed in ninth schedule.
A great victory and achievement to overcome all the constraints and maintaining its dignity in exercising all its powers provided by Indian constitution.
Now when the instrument of PIL (Public Interest Litigation) has been used across various sections of society, definitely Indian Judiciary has entered into its third phase, the Era of Activism, which is perceived as an interference by the other organs of the government.
The role of judiciary in police reforms and administrative reforms, like criminalization of politics, availability of NOTA option its emphasis on providing more autonomy to CBI, fixe tenure for bureaucrats and various other functions related to welfare state like cleansing of Yamuna river, regulation of acid sale, providing separate toilets to girl students, all this is a clear evidence of Judicial Activism.
Strangely, the advisory role of Supreme Court is not perceived as Judicial activism. Till date, been made to Supreme Court including Justice Ganguly case.
Judicial Activism is perceived as if judiciary is coming out of its shoes and breaking all its limits through some important judicial pronouncements. But if executive keeps on performing efficiently, judiciary can restraint itself, even though, it is fully aware of policy matters of executive. For example, in 2G Spectrum case, Supreme Court happens to review its own judgement that auction is the only method, now, it has been left to the executive to decide.
It is very important for judiciary, to follow a very creative and innovative approach to handle so many complicated issues and that’s why, these days, the procedure by law has been changed into due process of law by Indian Judiciary. Ultimately, every common man of the nation will look forward to the Supreme Court for Social Equity and Social Justice and this Judicial Imperialism has become need of the hour to restore the faith of the common man (AAM ADAMI) in the Indian Justice System considering the nervous breakdown of and malfunctioning of other organs of the system.
Test Series
SNM IAS Study Group announces module wise test series....

Read More
Student Test Schedule
Test Series Schedule for 2014 ...

Read More
Student Class Schedule
here m checking Student Class Schedule...

Read More
Exam Strategy
short description of Exam Strategy...

Read More
Study Material
small description about Study Material ...

Read More
Experts Advice
small description of Experts Advice...

Read More