Corporate Governance: Changing Ethical Perspective from Voluntary to Mandatory
All human beings are blessed with an inborn desire and tendency to contribute to society. This is firm belief of Alfred Adler, a renowned Psychologist in human nature that all of us are motivated by the energy of force of ‘Social Interest’. It is this innate tendency which compels us to do something for welfare and upliftment of our society.
For the 21st century Corporate Governance, framework is shifting to voluntary to mandatory regime. The new Indian company law includes a novel provision which mandates that companies spend 2% of their profits in Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR). Clause 135 of law mandates that every company with a network of more than Rs. 500 crore or a turnover of over Rs. 1000 crore, or net profit of more than Rs. 2% of its average net profits it has made in 3 preceding years in CSR every financial year. Although a positive obligation in cost upon Company’s Board to ensure such expenditure, companies are free to formulate and implement their own policies and can explain their reasons for non fulfillment of the requirement.
The very nature of the term ‘Responsibility’, used in CSR indicates a subjective phenomenon. An individual or an organization becomes responsible because of personal values, morals, which become a guiding force coming from within. Under this sense of responsibility, CSR policies and reports are usually designed to inform investors, shareholders, and other stakeholders about said and environmental performance and philosophy of a company.
While all companies are encouraged to consider compliance with CSR guidelines, it is entirely voluntary and without any regulatory or contractual obligation. The idea is for companies to have the consciousness to give something back to the community (Social Interest) to make CSR and major contributor to growth and quality of life of common people. Now, normative value and efficacy of purely voluntary CSR initiatives is under tremendous stress globally.
By putting it under mandatory, stronger regulatory framework internal responsibility has been converted into external accountability. But still this law does not seek to implement, enforce or correct CSR policies of industrial companies or monitor and regulate activates under it. CSR is not what companies do with their profits but how they make them. It is means which are more important than ends. Making large profits by selling hard drugs while damaging many lives in the process of then using a portion of profits, even exceeding 2% to set up world’s best clinics to rehabilitate drug addicts puts a Big Question Mark of what, how and why of CSR initative. Corporate Governance ethics requires company to act beyond its legal obligation and to integrate social, environmental and ethical concern into its business process.