GUIDELINES OF JUDICIARY IN MAINTAINING CONSTITUTIONAL DISCIPLINE

“To take a life when a life has been lost is revenge, not justice.”
                                                                                              - Desmond Tutu


The court decided that inordinate delay in deciding a mercy petition is a valid supervening factor, which can render the execution of a convict unconstitutional. The court rejected the government’s demand that even if the delay caused seems to be undue, the matter must be referred back to the executive and a decision must not be taken by the judiciary. The court reasoned that it was the custodian and enforcer of fundamental rights and the final interpreter of the Constitution. Further, it said, the court was best equipped to adjudicate the content of those rights and their requirements in a particular situation. Accepting the government’s contention would mean that the court cannot give relief to an individual for the violation of Article 21.

“Like the death sentence is passed lawfully, the execution of the sentence must also be in consonance with the constitutional mandate and not in violation of the constitutional principles”.
- Supreme Court Bench, on the inordinate delay in the execution of death sentences.


Guidelines:

1. Solitary or single-cell confinement prior to the rejection of mercy petition by the President is unconstitutional.

2. Superintendent of jails must intimate the rejection of mercy petitions to the nearest legal aid centre, apart from intimating the convicts, so that they get the requisite legal aid to challenge the rejection on the grounds of supervening events, if any.

3. Once the Governor rejects a mercy petition, the Central government must fix a time limit for the State government authorities to forward all relevant documents about the death-row convict.

4. A convict is entitled to be informed in writing by the Governor of the decision to reject the mercy petition. This decision should forthwith be communicated to the convict and his family in writing or through some other mode of communication available.

5. All States should inform the prisoner and their family members of the rejection of the mercy petition by the President forthwhile in writing.

6. Death convicts are entitled as a right to receive a copy of the rejection of the mercy petition by the President and the Governor.
7. A minimum of be stipulated between the receipt of communication of the rejection of the mercy petition and the scheduled date of execution for the following reasons:
(a) to allow the prisoner to prepare himself mentally for execution, prepare his will, and settle other earthly affairs; and
(b) to allow the prisoner to have a last and final meeting with his family members.
The superintendent of the jail has the obligation to inform the family members of the convict about the rejection of mercy petition in time.

8. Regular mental health evaluation of all death-row convicts and appropriate medical care to be given to those in need.

9. On the basis of medical reports by government doctors and psychiatrists the prison superintendent should satisfy himself that the prisoner is in a fit physical and mental condition to be executed. If the superintendent is of the opinion that the prisoner is not fit, he should forthwith stop the execution, produce the prisoner before a medical board, and forward a report to the State government.

10. Copies of relevant documents should be furnished to the prisoner within a week by the prison authorities to assist in making mercy petition and petitioning the courts.

11. Prison authorities must facilitate and allow a final meeting between the prisoner and his family and friends prior to his execution.

12. Post-mortem on death convicts after the execution is obligatory. The court found this necessary to reveal whether the prisoner died as a result of the dislocation of the cervical vertebrate or by strangulation, which results on account of too long a drop. Post-mortem, the court held, would ensure just, fair and reasonable procedure of execution of the death sentence.

The Supreme Court’s judgment has raised hopes that in future, execution of the death sentence may become near impossible, even though imposition of the death sentence itself is constitutionally permissible.
Test Series
SNM IAS Study Group announces module wise test series....

Read More
Student Test Schedule
Test Series Schedule for 2014 ...

Read More
Student Class Schedule
here m checking Student Class Schedule...

Read More
Exam Strategy
short description of Exam Strategy...

Read More
Study Material
small description about Study Material ...

Read More
Experts Advice
small description of Experts Advice...

Read More