SEPARATION OF POWERS

In India, there are mainly three organs of the Government; i.e., Legislature, Executive and Judiciary. India is a welfare state, and being a welfare state, Government plays a very dominant role in moulding the society; or in large perspective; the State. Directive principles laid down in Part IV of the Indian Constitution established duty on the Government to seek welfare of the people. Legislature is to legislate laws and enact laws for achieving the welfare of the people. Executive are given the responsibility to execute the laws made by the legislature and the Judiciary to adjudicate them. Moreover, the Supreme Court has been made the protector and guardian of the Constitution.

As there has been constant inaction from the legislative organ of the government to solve the major issues which people are facing, the judiciary had stepped into the shoes of the legislature. The legislature has mainly two important duty to perform, i.e., to reform the laws to meet the present situation and to enact laws which may be necessary to remedy the future wrongs that may arise in course of development in science and technology or due to progress in society and criminal or wrongful intent in the minds of the people.

For these reasons, the Hon’ble Supreme Court of India has expanded Article interpretation right to bail, the right to a speedy trial, immunity against cruel and unusual punishment, the right to dignified treatment in custodial institutions, the right to legal aid in criminal proceedings and above all the right to live with basic human dignity. It has also established new doctrines, such as, public trust doctrine, doctrine of promissory estoppels, doctrine of absolute liability, and host of principles such as polluter’s pay principle, etc. and offered guidelines in most important case as those relating to women, i.e., sexual harassment at work places, and most importantly laid down the foundation of Public Interest Litigation.

As rightly pointed out by M.C. Chagla, former Chief Justice of India, that “the Courts are not a department of Government. They are an authority coordinate with the Legislature and the Executive. Even Parliament, however wide and vast its powers, can only function under the Constitution. Even if legislation is passed by an overwhelming majority and Parliament has expressed its clear intention in no unequivocal terms, the legislation can be tested on the anvil of judicial review and if it falls the test, Parliament must submit to the decision of the Court. It is a mistake to call this a confrontation between Parliament and the Judiciary. Each is discharging its duty assigned to it by the Constitution. If we have faith in our Constitution, we should call it collaboration between two coordinate authorities rather than confrontation.”

Henceforth, it can be said that the rule of separation of power in today’s scenario cannot be worked out in a proper way. There is a need for a new and better doctrine which serves the purpose of the present democratic need, whether it is a parliamentary or presidential type of government. If we take the background of the major countries like USA, UK, India, Russia, France, Germany, Spain and UAE, it can be seen if there is no complete separation of power which Montesquieu had advocated. All the organs of the Government are subject to each other’s scrutiny by way of checks and balance. Thus, it can be better said that all the organs of the government should behave in a way that they do not violate the principal law or the rule of law of the country and it should be upheld in all circumstances for the better protection of the rights, liberties and freedoms of the people of that state. So, each organ are impliedly required to restraint their powers to the sphere which has been provided or set forth in the Constitution and to undertake steps that serves the purpose for which it is there. Any act, inaction or abuse of such powers by one organ calls for interference of the other organ.
Test Series
SNM IAS Study Group announces module wise test series....

Read More
Student Test Schedule
Test Series Schedule for 2014 ...

Read More
Student Class Schedule
here m checking Student Class Schedule...

Read More
Exam Strategy
short description of Exam Strategy...

Read More
Study Material
small description about Study Material ...

Read More
Experts Advice
small description of Experts Advice...

Read More